Singapore needs more “generalist” doctors than specialists, med schools say
The deans of three medical schools in Singapore say the city-state needs more “generalist” doctors who are skilled enough to treat a patient with several medical conditions to avoid having patients switch from one specialist doctor to another.
“Increasingly, I think that’s what we need in the health system – we need generalists,” said Associate Professor Yeoh Khay Guan, who is dean of the Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine at the National University of Singapore (NUS).”It’s not very good if our elderly parents see five doctors. It’s better if there’s also a generalist to look after their needs.”
This does not necessarily mean just general practitioners, but also those trained in family medicine, and geriatric and palliative care.
Figures from the Singapore Medical Council showed that niche fields like renal medicine and hand surgery are among the disciplines with biggest%age growths.
But there are bright spots for the general disciplines too – internal medicine, for instance, saw an increase of 50% between 2012 and last year. This field deals with a wide range of medical conditions and focuses on treating a person as a whole, rather than focusing on a single organ or area.
In the same period, the number of palliative-care doctors doubled, while the geriatric medicine specialists went up by a third.
These generalists are necessary in an ageing population where many elderly people have multiple health problems, said Professor James Best, dean of Nanyang Technological University’s Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine.”(It is) holistic medicine, where the doctor looks at the whole person – not just his heart or his kidneys,” he said. “We also need to consider the patient in the context of his family and society.”
Yet, getting young doctors into these fields is not always easy. For example, said Dr Loke Wai Chiong, who is Deloitte South-east Asia’s healthcare sector leader, specialties such as surgery are often more lucrative, making them an attractive option.
Other specialties may not require a doctor to deal with seriously ill patients or emergencies, allowing for a better work-life balance.
“Plus, specialties such as geriatrics and palliative medicine can be viewed as ‘depressing’ because they deal with older patients,” Dr.Loke added. “(Some may) have many different diseases, all potentially exacerbating each other, with no chance of a complete cure.”
One way of getting medical students more interested in these areas is through giving them role models to emulate, suggested Professor Thomas Coffman, dean of the Duke-NUS Medical School.
“As these specialties grow and as medical students see people working… they can see how compelling these areas are,” he said.
Another is tweaking the curriculum to reflect the population’s needs, which is what NUS has done.
“We plan our curriculum according to what we think our students need to know when they are doctors,” Prof Yeoh said. “As the demographics change… we try and shift our curriculum towards those areas, to give (them) better coverage and more exposure.”
But in fact, it is also a challenge for medical schools to keep the curriculum up to date, since medical knowledge increases so rapidly.
The deans said that the solution is to train students in the art of learning, rather than cramming their heads with facts.
For example, Duke-NUS students take “open-laptop” exams where they can use any reliable information they find, Prof Coffman said.”Medical thinking… is not a memorization of facts,” he added. “You have to be open to developments, and how to evaluate (them) and incorporate them into practice.”
